[Image by Shane Finkelstein]

“Waitress” is Baked to Perfection

06:00 September 18, 2025
By: Shane Finkelstein

Waitress at JPAC

It may have taken me 10 years to finally make it to a show at the Jefferson Performance Arts Center, but I already want to go back for a second performance of the Tony-nominated musical Waitress.

Although the story of a small-town girl with big dreams looking to escape an abusive marriage is a common one, the acting, catchy tunes, and somewhat-surprising ending made it a hit on Broadway and a show worth catching this weekend at the JPAC in Metairie.

If you haven't been before, the 10-year-old theater boasts comfortable, wide seats, plenty of leg room, great line of sight, and excellent acoustics. The traveling performance of Waitress has masterful set pieces that easily slide across the stage and a really unique way of featuring the musicians tucked behind what would normally be the counter in a diner.

[Image by Shane Finkelstein]

The story follows the life of 30-something Jenna, played by Meredith Owens, who is a master pie maker at Joe's Pie Diner, where her friends and co-workers encourage her to submit her pies for the big national pie competition coming to town. Before the competition takes place, however, Jenna's life is turned upside down by the arrival of the handsome new Doctor Pomatter (Jake Wynne-Wilson), as well as a new bun in the oven provided by her abusive loser of a husband Earl, played masterfully by Matthew Welch.

While the first set mostly featured the struggling waitresses commiserating over their shared troubles, the second set shines brightest when co-workers Dawn (Chase Kamata) and Becky (Whitney Mixon) find love and happiness with men that shower them with affection and attention. Though there's plenty of infidelity to go around, Jenna finally figures out that it doesn't take a man to make you happy and that happiness comes from within.

[Image by Shane Finkelstein]

This was Saenger-quality theater at the JPAC, kind of like seeing a show off-Broadway, with acting and singing on par with anything featured at the prestigious New Orleans venue. Every one of the actors played their roles so perfectly that it's hard to pinpoint one that stood above the rest. For me, Chase Kamata and her love interest, Ogie (Scott Souber), were just so entertaining and fun to watch during their goofy, yet lovable interactions. I also just can't get over how good Matthew Welch played the dumb redneck. While Meredith Owens will deservedly get most of the accolades, the acting in Waitress was perfect from top to bottom.

This may not be the only musical worth seeing at the JPAC this year, but it is definitely one you won't want to miss. You have one more weekend to get on the bandwagon, and good seats at very reasonable prices are still available.

Sign Up!

FOR THE INSIDE SCOOP ON DINING, MUSIC, ENTERTAINMENT, THE ARTS & MORE!