[Courtesy of Netflix]

New Orleans Film Festival Movie Review: Jay Kelly

06:00 October 29, 2025
By: Fritz Esker

Jay Kelly (2025), from the New Orleans Film Festival

George Clooney has been getting Oscar buzz as the lead in director Noah Baumbach's Jay Kelly, portraying an aging movie star heading to Europe for a career tribute with his long-suffering manager Ron (Adam Sandler). It's a good film and a good performance by Clooney, so there may indeed be a nomination in his future.

Clooney's Kelly is facing a crossroads as the youngest of his two daughters (Grace Edwards) is about to head off to college. Kelly hasn't been a deadbeat dad, but he has definitely been the type of person to prioritize his career over family time. His oldest daughter (Riley Keough) still resents him for this. Ron also has two daughters, and Kelly's demands keep him from them for long stretches, as well.

At two hours and 12 minutes, Jay Kelly rambles a bit in stretches, and a few of the comedy bits feel a tad forced. However, for the most part, it's an effective character study. While the movie star life that Kelly lives is a privileged one, it comes with its share of downsides, too. Kelly tries to reconnect with an old friend (Billy Crudup), only to learn he's exceedingly bitter about Kelly's success. The people he spends the most time with are all people on his payroll, which creates a barrier to forming genuine friendships.

Somewhat appropriately for a film about a movie star, Jay Kelly is often at its best when Clooney is letting his pure movie star charisma shine. There's no better example of this than when Kelly finds himself on a packed train in France with a crowd of ordinary people. At first, it seems like this might lead to a tense an awkward encounter, but Kelly effortlessly charms and delights everyone in the train.

Baumbach's script (co-written with Emily Mortimer) also does a good job of making Kelly human. He's a flawed man who has clearly made some mistakes in his life but he's not a bad one, either. Like everyone who reaches middle age, he's just a person looking back on his life and contemplating the choices he has made.

Jay Kelly will get Netflix's usual extremely limited theatrical release on November 14.

Sign Up!

FOR THE INSIDE SCOOP ON DINING, MUSIC, ENTERTAINMENT, THE ARTS & MORE!